My Mum has always made lovely peanut butter cookies. I've grown up with a love of peanut butter and want my daughter to do so too!
Another Mum currently doing Baby Led Weaning asked for low sugar biscuit recipes so it wasn't the end of the world if her son swiped her biscuit. I decided to see if I could reduce the sugar in the PB recipe, I also had some very ripe bananas to use. I also had a moment of madness and put too much egg in the recipe, but it worked anyway! They fall somewhere on the cake-cookie spectrum, hence the name cakie, you can dollop the mix free form, use mini muffin tin or pipe onto tray. These are yum (in my opinion) and recipe made 40 (I'll do half recipe in brackets in case you only want to make 20), so each cookie has 2.5g sugar in.
Preheat oven to 180°C and grease baking tray/ mini muffin pan etc.
Ingredients for 40 (20)
2 very ripe bananas mashed (1 banana)100g soft butter (50g)
100g sugar (50g)
120g PB (60g)
2 large or 3 small eggs beaten (1 large egg)
1 tsp baking powder (0.5tsp)
250-300g SR flour (130g)
0.5 tsp Vanilla essence (few drops)
1. Mix the soft butter and sugar into the mashed banana and mix to form a smooth paste.
2. Add peanut butter gradually... don't worry too much if it doesn't mix well at this stage
3. Gradually stir in the beaten eggs and vanilla essence
4. Weigh out full amount of flour (300g for full recipe), add the baking powder and then sift it in to the mix in approx 50g amounts... the consistency you're looking for is a thick cakey sort of consistency. I used three eggs and needed all the flour.
5. Grease baking tray or mini muffin pan. Either dollop heaped teaspoons full onto baking tray or put into piping bag* and pipe 3/4" wide strips onto tray. You can also use a mini muffin tray if you want more cake shaped portions.
6. You can top with a light dusting of sugar if you'd like. I push "dolloped" ones down with a fork to flatten slightly.
7. Bake at 180°C for 15-25 minutes (depends on size) remove when golden and ridges/edges are just starting to brown
*I find zip lock bags work well. Spoon mix into a small ziplock/press and seal type bag, seal the top then snip a corner off and use as a piping bag... Nothing comes out the top as its closed!
The finished article, from left to right:
Piped, muffin, free form with forked top.